The Best Emo Album of the ’90s Might Actually Be a Grunge Masterpiece

In 1994, grunge was still the dominating force in rock music, although it was slowly starting to lose its spotlight in favor of nu metal and pop punk, after the tragic suicide of Nirvana frontman Kurt Cobain.

However, and although its main stylistic points lived on with the divisive post-grunge trends, the Seattle sound would go on to inspire pretty much every band in the ’90s alternative scene, regardless of genre.

Among the underground genres that succeeded grunge was emo, which originated in the late ’80s but had its explosion the following decade, with Sunny Day Real Estate as a flagship band.

Their debut album, “Diary”, remains a seminal release within the genre, although it could just as easily fit within the wide borders of the grunge sound.

Therefore, in tribute to the record’s 30th anniversary, we look back on this classic to see if one of emo’s most defining releases is actually a grunge gem in disguise.

Sub Pop’s Next Big Thing
Natives of Seattle, Sunny Day Real Estate were formed in 1992 by guitarist Dan Hoerner, bassist Nate Mendel, and drummer William Goldsmith. Initially an instrumental outfit, the group later recruited Jeremy Enigk as a singer and second guitarist.

Influenced by OG emo acts like Rites of Spring, the band played a raw, hardcore-inspired sound, which was mellowed out by Enigk’s emotionally delicate vocal delivery.

This encouraged Sunny Day Real Estate to lean more on their melodic side, adding an indie-tinged sensibility to their style, which would be simply coined emo, in contrast to the harsher version of emotional hardcore.

The band attracted the attention of the legendary Seattle label Sub Pop, home of grunge legends like Nirvana, Mudhoney, and Soundgarden, which gave it enough credit to be seen as a driving force in ’90s rock trendsetting.

Sub Pop thus became the home for Sunny Day Real Estate, where they released their debut album “Diary” in May 1994, changing the alternative world in the process.

The Missing Link Between Hardcore, Grunge, and Indie
Celebrated as one of the finest albums of the decade, “Diary” occupied a previously empty space in the Seattle rock scene, due to its unique sound.

Combining the urgency and intensity of emotional hardcore, the melodic sensibility and intimate delivery of indie, and the well-crafted quiet/loud songwriting dynamics of grunge, the record was the missing link between these genres.

The beauty of “Diary” is that it could easily fit among any of those styles, while still feeling somewhat out of place, which led to its place as a landmark in the nascent emo scene, more specifically, the Midwest emo subgenre.

With Enigk’s subdued vocals and cryptic, plus the group’s twinkly guitar riffs and intense dynamics, they laid the blueprints that acts like American Football would later popularize even further.

Although not fitting with the stereotypical grunge sound, Sunny Day Real Estate’s association with Sub Pop, reluctance to embrace fame and do wide media coverages, and elements of their songwriting tied them to the genre.

Legacy of ‘Diary’
Even though it never achieved true mainstream success in the style of Nirvana or other Sub Pop darlings, “Diary” sold over 200,000 copies and it’s the 7th best-selling record in the label’s History.

Besides that, it’s also widely seen as a genre-defining moment for emo, and a landmark in alternative culture, with singles “Seven” and “In Circles” being often praised as some of the finest moments in the genre.

But “Diary” has a lot more to offer than its era-defining singles, with deeper cuts like the tortured “Song About an Angel”, the melodically intricate “47”, or the gut-wrenching closer “Sometimes” being incredible moments of alt-rock songwriting.

The band’s confident and dynamic instrumentation led by Enigk and Hoerner’s dual guitar attack, as well as Mendel and Goldsmith’s flawless rhythm section create a masterful balance between hardcore urgency, pop accessibility, and melodic beauty.

The highlight, however, is Enigk’s passionate vocal delivery and melancholic lyrics, which truly tie the full listening experience together with ease.

Unfortunately, due to internal tensions, the band broke up in 1995, shortly before the release of their underrated self-titled sophomore record.

This hindered their mainstream exposure and led to increased disinterest in any of their following releases amid several short-term reunions, even though their discography has remained incredibly consistent.

Mendel and Goldsmith famously joined Foo Fighters, with the bassist remaining in the line-up until today, and Sunny Day Real Estate’s status as a defining band in the birth of emo has only become more significant with time, propelled by the masterpiece that is “Diary”.

But Is It Grunge?
The final part of this article should be devoted to the initial hypothesis we offered: is this seminal emo record a grunge masterpiece in disguise?

“Diary” might not be the immediate response when you think about classic grunge albums, but elements of the genre are clearly present.

From the way the band presented themselves and shunned any thought of fame, to production and mixing choices, to the creative employment of quiet/loud dynamics, there are undeniable influences of the Seattle sound in this record.

And this is far from surprising, considering how omnipresent Nirvana and co. were at this time, and how record labels were desperate to push this style and sound to all their artists.

Furthermore, if we expand the grunge umbrella to artists like Smashing Pumpkins or Stone Temple Pilots, which offered their own indie-flavored takes on the genre, then Sunny Day Real Estate and “Diary” definitely have a place there as well.

However, to reduce this incredible record to the restrictions of the grunge sound is doing it a disservice. While it was a part of that scene and it borrows a considerable amount of stylistic elements from it, “Diary” stands as a unique piece of work that united the hardcore, indie, and alternative worlds, and paved the way for an entire genre to emerge.

Related Articles

The Day the Music Burned

It was the biggest disaster in the history of the music business — and almost nobody knew. This is the story of the 2008 Universal fire.
Chuck Berry, 1958.CreditCreditPhoto Illustration by Sean Freeman & Eve Steben for The New York Times. Source Photograph: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images.