How Sacramento Skate-Punks Created an Alternative Metal Masterpiece with “White Pony”

The Birth of a Genre-Blending Experiment

Theoretically, every musical genre can coexist if crafted thoughtfully. While some combinations, like symphonic metal, emerge naturally from their shared elements, others push boundaries to unexpected extremes. Take the eclectic style of Poppy, whose music defies categorization with a resounding “yes” to every genre. But even classic genre fusions had to start somewhere. Every movement needs a trailblazer — an artist or group daring enough to chart new territory. For alternative metal, one of the most influential pioneers was Deftones with their 2000 album White Pony.

Skateboards, Friendships, and Adrenaline

Before White Pony took shape, Deftones had already laid the groundwork for their groundbreaking sound. The band formed in 1988 in Sacramento, California, a group of childhood friends immersed in the local skateboarding culture and united by a shared love of music. Vocalist Chino Moreno, guitarist Stephen Carpenter, bassist Chi Cheng, drummer Abe Cunningham, and later keyboardist/turntablist Frank Delgado brought diverse musical tastes to the table: one loved hip-hop, another embraced post-punk and new wave, while another thrived on the heaviest metal available. Rather than sacrificing individuality, they blended their influences to create something unique.

Deftones released their debut album, Adrenaline, in 1995. While raw and energetic, the album was a starting point rather than a definitive statement. At the time, the band’s primary focus was simply gaining recognition. As Chino Moreno once recalled:

“I still didn’t really have that big of a dream. I was just stoked that we had a record deal. Someone was interested in us and wanted to invest money in us, and thought that we could generate money and crowds and do something good for their label. So we were stoked on that.”

However, Adrenaline was just the beginning. By the time they released their sophomore album, Around the Fur (1997), Deftones had begun to refine their sound, incorporating experimental elements and showcasing their potential for growth. While both albums could be categorized as alternative metal, the band’s creative ambitions were far from satisfied.

The Emotional Core of White Pony

Released in 2000, White Pony was a revelation. The album defied expectations, both for the band and the genre. Exhausted from relentless touring and under pressure to deliver quickly, Deftones made the bold decision to prioritize creativity over speed. They entered the studio without a clear vision, instead allowing their emotions and instincts to guide the writing process. Bassist Chi Cheng later reflected:

“We didn’t feel like we had anything to lose. So we made the record we wanted to make.”

The process wasn’t without conflict. Chino Moreno’s choice to play rhythm guitar on the album led to tension with guitarist Stephen Carpenter, but the band ultimately worked through their differences. The real challenge lay in balancing the diverse musical ingredients they wanted to incorporate: trip-hop, post-hardcore, shoegaze, post-rock, and progressive elements. Initially, the mix didn’t quite gel.

A breakthrough came with the creation of “Change (In the House of Flies),” a pivotal track that epitomized the band’s collaborative spirit. As Moreno recalled:

“When we wrote ‘Change,’ that was one of those defining songs where we all wrote together. It started out with Stephen and I playing guitar and Frank doing his keyboard thing over it. Right then, everybody joined in. Nobody told anybody else what to do; it all just came out freely. That’s when it all started to come together.”

A Masterpiece Takes Shape

With their creative chemistry clicking, the band completed White Pony. Featuring guest appearances from Tool’s Maynard James Keenan and Stone Temple Pilots’ Scott Weiland, and wrapped in a minimalist yet striking album cover, the record was a bold statement of alternative metal’s potential.

The album’s tracks showcased incredible range. Songs like “Elite” and “Digital Bath” channeled the band’s playful, high-energy ethos, while “Passenger” and “Pink Maggit” exemplified their willingness to take creative risks. The standout track, “Knife Prty,” featured an unforgettable solo — not from a guitar, but from an actress friend of the band who delivered an intense vocal performance of haunting screams and ethereal melodies, as if the world were ending.

Legacy of White Pony

White Pony solidified Deftones as pioneers of alternative metal. The album’s innovation and emotional depth proved that genre boundaries were meant to be broken. Paradoxically, its songs felt both individually distinct and essential to the album’s cohesive whole.

In the years since, Deftones have continued to evolve, never compromising on quality or creativity. Like a fine wine, their music has matured with time. Yet, among their impressive discography, White Pony remains a singular achievement — a genre-blending masterpiece that redefined what alternative metal could be.

 

Become a Member and get access to shows, buy/sell tickets and network with fans & bands from across Canada. Sign-up for free!

Related Articles

The Day the Music Burned

It was the biggest disaster in the history of the music business — and almost nobody knew. This is the story of the 2008 Universal fire.
Chuck Berry, 1958.CreditCreditPhoto Illustration by Sean Freeman & Eve Steben for The New York Times. Source Photograph: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images.

Responses

Upcoming Events